Police took my guns!

Speaking with your attorney outside of public forums might be your best bet.

Depends on a whole host of potential factors, which might or might not have been present. As well, you're in NY, a place where the rabid "leaders" have a wild hair, right now, for all things "gun."

Lawyer

Call an attorney............IMO.

Talk to a lawyer, then do what he says

^^^^^^^^^ What he said. And quickly. ^^^^^^^^^^^^^

wouldnt they need a warrant to confiscate any firearm NOT involved in the accident? I can see them taking the firearm that discharged the round.. as it is technically discharge of a firearm in public and may or may not be a criminal offense in NY.. but to then take all of them in the house?

Thats like having ALL of your cars impounded because you got a a DUI while driving only ONE of them.

Lawyer up immediately

How's the guy on the other side of the wall?

Find a lawyer that wants to raise some cain, and think about moving to Texas lol

And you're in NY. Double whammy.

Lawyer, NOW.

Much as I dislike them get a lawyer NOW.

Get a lawyer...especially in the PRNY...

Did they say why they confiscated your property? Did they give you a receip?

I don't know if anyone has mentioned this yet but, lawyer up!

... and then clean house.

Buy a dark mask and rubber gloves and call a lawyer.

Um, start by:

1) Getting off a public forum that can be read by anyone and used against you if they deem appropriate
2) Get a good attorney who does this type of work
3) Stop asking a bunch of laymen for advice

They took all your gunss because they are going to prove you are an irresponsible and negligent gun owner that shouldn't be allowed to own any firearms,wait for the letter revoking your License to own guns

This sounds like a NY thing. I've read reports of people having NDs in free states, and usually the cops will write a report, but not press charges. I may have heard of a story or two where the cops took the weapon that was involved in the ND, but nothing else.

I'm going to buck the trend and say keep asking strangers for advice.

No wait... on second thought, I'd get a lawyer. Final answer.

Get a lawyer 14

Bend over here it comes 1