Defensive Carry banner

1 - 20 of 20 Posts

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,418 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Well I'm finally back, got this gun almost 3 weeks ago but between work and life in general I have had very little free time for much of anything nonetheless a range trip. Finally got to take it out this past Sunday. Unfortunately, no pics since I don't own a camera and using my phone didn't occur to me, oh well next time.

First step in my trip was to reenact (with myself) the scene from Sudden Impact where Callaghan shows Horace his new .44 Automag...

I didn't fire a huge number of rounds, mainly due to my supply being limited and the fact the .357 Sig isn't exactly cheap. I shot 100 rounds of Fed American Eagle FMJ 125gr and 25 rounds of Speer Gold Dot 125gr. I split it up to 50 FMJ, 13 JHP, 50 FMJ, 12 JHP for variety and testing the weapon under different cleanliness and heating conditions. I only have two magazines as of now so that kind of slows things down. I had zero malfunctions of any kind, very please.

As far as the shooting experience, the recoil isn't really harsh, it is more of a sudden snap but not quite as strong as .40 is. However, it is LOUD. I didn't notice any flash, but it was a dry sunny day so it was impossible to know, I imagine in the dark their would be one. The LEM trigger takes a little bit of getting used to, but I'm comfortable with it now and really like it. I can see how it really does allow for faster follow up shots but it is unlike any trigger I've ever used before.

What I Like:
-The quality is immaculate, everything is machined perfectly and clearly the tolerances are extremely tight. I own Glocks and M&Ps and they are well made, but HK just takes it to another level.
-The trigger, it takes some getting used to but once you get comfortable it is very good, also the hammer seems to cycle faster than any hammer fired weapon I have ever seen.
-It is reasonably small and light, I don't have a holster for it yet (on order) but intend to carry it IWB and expect it will be just fine for that purpose.
-The .357 Sig cartridge delivers excellent firepower and performs well through auto glass and sheet metal, this is of particular importance to me since I consider an attempted car jacking to be one of the most like SD shooting scenarios.

What I Don't Like:
-The mag release (on the trigger guard) is kind of awkward. I'm used to the conventional American style thumb activated push button. This one you have to kind of shift your grip and then pull it down, I'm going to play with the interchangeable backstraps to see if this can be fixed.
-Parts/magazine availability is not exactly easy, panic or not. It came with 2 mags, I've been looking for more but so far can't find any anywhere. The search continues.
-Not really a 'dislike' per se, but the takedown procedure is kind of weird. You literally take a large piece out of the gun which is kind of disconcerting that a major part can be removed so easily!
-The costs involved are steep in every regard. I paid roughly $1000 for the gun after tax, mags cost roughly $60 each and .357 Sig ammo is not cheap. To be fair, I knew all this before I bought anything, and this definitely was an indulgent purchase. I've been fortunate to have had a good past couple of years with the business and decided to treat myself. I'm not into things like expensive cigars or clothes etc. but I definitely do appreciate fine machinery. I'm thinking of getting a .40 barrel for it, but they seem to cost about as much as a used Glock so I don't see that happening soon.


Kind of a funny side note, the range (outdoor) was unusually quiet despite it being a weekend and great weather (sunny, 75 or so), I was there alone and there were only a few other shooters. The noise of the .357 definitely caused others to pay attention to me! There were two guys on the same range next to me who were definitely 'bubbas' (no offense to any bubbas on here, but one reminded me of Dale Gribble from King of the Hill) who had 1911s and some revolvers, during a cease fire they started talking to me asking what I was shooting. I said an HK P2000SK and got a 'huh?' response...I explained that it is the gun the Border Patrol use (mostly true, they use it in .40 and mostly the full size model) and that rang a bell for them.

All in all, I really like the gun. After I get my holster (Comptac kydex IWB) it will certainly go into my EDC rotation with my Glock and my M&Ps. Yes, HKs are expensive, but I feel that I have gotten my money's worth without a doubt. Right now, I only have a small amount of .357 Sig ammo on hand (25 rounds of Gold Dot 125gr), but enough for EDC use. Unlike how I normally treat my EDC guns by unloading them every night, I'm not going to do that with this one due to the risk of setback with the very high pressure loading of the .357 Sig. I'm very glad I bought this gun and I expect it will serve me well for many years to come.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
36,326 Posts
The H&K P2000SK is one heck of a good gun. Extremely reliable, capable, fully-ambidextrous controls. You're right about the magazine release being a bit different than most everything else on the market. For me, that's its only real downside. Great choice!

Once you're really up to speed with it, if you're willing, feel free to post some target pics. It'd be nice to show what this gun's capable of.

Congratulations on the new stable pony. :smile:
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,418 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
The H&K P2000SK is one heck of a good gun. Extremely reliable, capable, fully-ambidextrous controls. You're right about the magazine release being a bit different than most everything else on the market. For me, that's its only real downside. Great choice!

Once you're really up to speed with it, if you're willing, feel free to post some target pics. It'd be nice to show what this gun's capable of.

Congratulations on the new stable pony. :smile:
Thanks, yea next time I take it out I'll take pics. I'm a decent, not great, but decent shooter in general and found the SK easy to shoot accurately, I think the trigger helps a lot. Some people complain about the somewhat unusual sight picture but I have no issue with it.

When I got it I texted my father, who has an affinity for snub revolvers, he looked up how much it cost and was flabbergasted that I spent that much on a gun. I made up a story about how the .357 is a semi auto equivalent of the magnum and the SK is a subcompact equivalent to a revolver haha.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,675 Posts
The more you use the paddle style mag release, the more it makes sense. There are three ways folks press the paddle. One way with the thumb, as many are used to doing with button releases, second is with the trigger finger and third using both fingers. After years of shooting the HKs I've come to prefer the paddle lever mag release. It is the only release that I can use without changing my grip. It can be done very fast too.The different backstraps can have an effect on both grip and shooting speed. You may want to try both mag bases as well.

The SK is a terrific pistol. It always makes me smile when I shoot. It's just so competent. For practice I use both 10 and 13 round mags for the USPc. The 10 round mags can be found for much lower prices, or could before the current madness.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,268 Posts
As a long time revolver shooter, I love the LEM trigger. Nice smooth first pull and then just relax your trigger finger a little bit and you feel the reset point for quick follow-up shots that feel like SA. I have a 9mm P2000SK as my research has led me to believe that a .357 Sig out of a short barrel will give you the same ballistic performance as a 9mm +P out of the same gun but with all the muzzle flash and recoil of the .357 Sig round. It is truly a cartridge that needs a longer barrel to reach its potential as a .357 magnum clone. Without the longer barrel it is like shooting a .357 magnum round out of my snub nose revolver. I may gain a little velocity over a .38 spl but if I choose my .38 +P ammo carefully I can find some that will meet or exceed the performance of most .357 magnum rounds out of the same gun but with less recoil and flash. That is why most carry .38 +P in their small .357 mag guns.

However, if the ammo were not so expensive I would buy a full sized .357 sig in a heartbeat as I love hard recoiling and loud guns. I used to shoot .357 magnums from an 11 oz. snub nose for fun and they lit up the place and I had to use ear plugs and ear muffs to lower the volume. Enjoy the gun as you have good taste. :)
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
5,171 Posts
Try HKParts.net. Sometimes it takes a little while for them to get mags in and they won't be cheap, but the service is superior and the products will be genuine HK. Great review! I'm a bit of an HK fanboy myself!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
36,326 Posts
I'm a decent, not great, but decent shooter in general and found the SK easy to shoot accurately, I think the trigger helps a lot.
Some folks rail against the heavier trigger pull, many even complaining how it's not smooth as "buttah." If interested, you could always give H&K a call about their options for altering the trigger pull-weight, or give one of these gunsmiths a call about smoothing up the trigger/action: Gray Guns (Bruce Gray).

Prior discussion on action/trigger jobs for H&K's: click.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,121 Posts
I have the H&K 2000sk also and it is a great gun. The double recoil spring tames the recoil. I have .40 and it's recoil is as managble as many of my larger guns. I found that using 2 fingers on the paddles that the mag drops easily with very little pressure.

As many have suggested USP larger mags for back up or practice work well and are cheaper. I picked up 4 on gunbroker for $100. H&K gets mags in constantly. I am looking for some myself and the next delivery would be at the end of April: 706-568-1906 ext. 227 "Travis"

I also believe the quality of H&Ks are worth the price.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,418 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
I have the H&K 2000sk also and it is a great gun. The double recoil spring tames the recoil. I have .40 and it's recoil is as managble as many of my larger guns. I found that using 2 fingers on the paddles that the mag drops easily with very little pressure.

As many have suggested USP larger mags for back up or practice work well and are cheaper. I picked up 4 on gunbroker for $100. H&K gets mags in constantly. I am looking for some myself and the next delivery would be at the end of April: 706-568-1906 ext. 227 "Travis"

I also believe the quality of H&Ks are worth the price.
Thanks for the info and contact #, I'll look into that for SK mags. I bought 2 USPc mags from HK parts today, $40 each, I know they will stick out but they are more for range use than anything else so I don't mind the protrusion. I'll stick with the SK specific mags for carry, holster should be in tomorrow if UPS is telling the truth! Since I have a lunch meeting about a mile from where I live, I'll probably stop home if it is delivered in the morning and carry it for the afternoon/evening.

Now the quest shifts focus for ammo, maybe DHS can hook me up...
 

·
Administrator
Joined
·
21,398 Posts
I work the paddle with the middle finger of my shooting hand.

1: It forces the trigger finger up and away from the trigger during reloads.

2: I don't have to shift my grip as much and the longer finger seems to press back/in/down and seems more solid.

I've been so happy withe the light LEM in my P30LS that I just converted my HK45 to LEM. Even though the P30 trigger has been worked by Gray guns, I really like the trigger I ended up with in the 45, although I'm not using a standard configuration.

Now I just need a LEM kit for my P30S....and a P2000SK in 9mm. :biggrin2:


Good write up, thanks for sharing.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
36,326 Posts
I work the paddle with the middle finger of my shooting hand.
That's my method, as well, on the P2000SK.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
206 Posts
Congratulations on a fantastic gun! Many people that have not experienced the quality and feel of an HK will say that it is too expensive and not worth the investment. Most all of them will not say that after they have actually handled one.

While I don't have a P2000SK, it is certainly on my short-list! In the meantime, I'll have to make do with my USPc .357SIG. I love it!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,406 Posts
What I Like:
-The quality is immaculate, everything is machined perfectly and clearly the tolerances are extremely tight. I own Glocks and M&Ps and they are well made, but HK just takes it to another level.
-The trigger, it takes some getting used to but once you get comfortable it is very good, also the hammer seems to cycle faster than any hammer fired weapon I have ever seen.
-It is reasonably small and light, I don't have a holster for it yet (on order) but intend to carry it IWB and expect it will be just fine for that purpose.
-The .357 Sig cartridge delivers excellent firepower and performs well through auto glass and sheet metal, this is of particular importance to me since I consider an attempted car jacking to be one of the most like SD shooting scenarios.

What I Don't Like:
-The mag release (on the trigger guard) is kind of awkward. I'm used to the conventional American style thumb activated push button. This one you have to kind of shift your grip and then pull it down, I'm going to play with the interchangeable backstraps to see if this can be fixed.
-Parts/magazine availability is not exactly easy, panic or not. It came with 2 mags, I've been looking for more but so far can't find any anywhere. The search continues.
-Not really a 'dislike' per se, but the takedown procedure is kind of weird. You literally take a large piece out of the gun which is kind of disconcerting that a major part can be removed so easily!
-The costs involved are steep in every regard. I paid roughly $1000 for the gun after tax, mags cost roughly $60 each and .357 Sig ammo is not cheap. To be fair, I knew all this before I bought anything, and this definitely was an indulgent purchase. I've been fortunate to have had a good past couple of years with the business and decided to treat myself. I'm not into things like expensive cigars or clothes etc. but I definitely do appreciate fine machinery. I'm thinking of getting a .40 barrel for it, but they seem to cost about as much as a used Glock so I don't see that happening soon.


Kind of a funny side note, the range (outdoor) was unusually quiet despite it being a weekend and great weather (sunny, 75 or so), I was there alone and there were only a few other shooters. The noise of the .357 definitely caused others to pay attention to me! There were two guys on the same range next to me who were definitely 'bubbas' (no offense to any bubbas on here, but one reminded me of Dale Gribble from King of the Hill) who had 1911s and some revolvers, during a cease fire they started talking to me asking what I was shooting. I said an HK P2000SK and got a 'huh?' response...I explained that it is the gun the Border Patrol use (mostly true, they use it in .40 and mostly the full size model) and that rang a bell for them.
First let me thank you for an extremely LUCID thread/post, seem these days we have a rambling post!

I glad you had time to get out with your SK. Some notes from my experiences: You'll find the mag release takes time and training to get accustom to the release and you should be able to release and drop the mag with one hand for reloads. If the trigger is an issue after time, then you may wish to have a trigger job done. I did mine my self and all three of my are a V1. My 9mm has over ± 7,000 rounds with no failure to feeds. Now you need to get a 40 S&W barrel!

If you think it loud at an outdoor range, try it indoors! PM if you can find 357 Sig. SD ammo.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,418 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
First let me thank you for an extremely LUCID thread/post, seem these days we have a rambling post!

I glad you had time to get out with your SK. Some notes from my experiences: You'll find the mag release takes time and training to get accustom to the release and you should be able to release and drop the mag with one hand for reloads. If the trigger is an issue after time, then you may wish to have a trigger job done. I did mine my self and all three of my are a V1. My 9mm has over ± 7,000 rounds with no failure to feeds. Now you need to get a 40 S&W barrel!

If you think it loud at an outdoor range, try it indoors! PM if you can find 357 Sig. SD ammo.
You're welcome, after all I did have three weeks to play around with it at home before I ever got to shoot it! I'm working on the techniques for the release, getting there progressively. I like the trigger how it is now, provided it doesn't change I think I'll leave it stock most likely. A .40 barrel is in the cards, eventually. Those things are so darn expensive though (like $300). I'll PM about SD ammo if I find any, can't let the masses know of such a precious commodity! All the ammo I got was from the LGS where I bought the gun, they set it aside for me when I ordered the gun, I paid full (MSRP) price for it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,406 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
332 Posts
Personally, I find the mag release on HKs and some Walthers (P99, PPS) to be one of the BEST features---just use your trigger finger---super easy. As mentioned by some already, replace with the larger version available from HKParts...
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,418 Posts
Discussion Starter · #19 · (Edited)
Got more ammo today and an impromptu range session. The LGS where I bought the gun got in a shipment of ammo in general today, I knew this for several days, but the guy I deal with there didn't know the exact contents until it arrived today. They are an honest operation, they haven't raised and prices but have put reasonable restrictions on some calibers. Range ammo is limited to 2 boxes per person in 9mm, 40, 45, and .223/5.56 but no quantity limit on other calibers. The only catch is that you have to use their range at the time of purchase ($16 for a half hour on the indoor range). There is not limit on SD ammo in any caliber. I bought 5 50 round boxes of WWB FMJ 125gr and one 50 round box of Gold Dot 125gr, paid for my ammo, took all 300 rounds to the range, shot one box of WWB and left haha! They didn't say anything as I was walking out with a paper bag that weighed about 12lbs, the fact that I have spent about $1300 in their store in the last month may be part of the reason for that I guess. My 357 Sig supply now is 250 FMJ and 75 JHP, I'm comfortable for now.

I took phone pics of my target, if someone can tell me how to post a pic from my phone I'll put it up. As you (hopefully) will see, I am still getting used to the cartridge, I'm pulling somewhat left, not down left, just left. Not terrible (still within 8 ring) but I'm still adjusting.

photo.jpg
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
5,171 Posts
Count me as another guy that's grown to prefer the HK/euro-style mag release vs. the American "standard" push button release. It seems to be much harder to accidentally pop the mag out while carrying in the holster than the American style that we're all used to. And I find it faster and easier to get to than the traditional button.
 
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Top