Joined
·
740 Posts
Thanks for a greast report. Sorry about the P22. I'm sure you're real proud of your son. It's wonderful to see the youngsters enjoying firearms and performing so well with them. Give him my best wishes.
Range reports here
Ok guys...
FIRST........I HATE that WALTHER P22...........I would suggest to NEVER buy one.. My Son Steve, shot his Walther tonight (the one I bought him for Christmas) The gun is a real POS...:rant: ...I hate to say bad things BUT out of 50 rounds of Rem yellow jackets............25 were FTF or FTE..:rant: NOT a good thing........we tried CCI........and the same thing happened........Bringing it back and throwing it at em..:rant: . I'm gonna get him a Ruger MKII K512 like i knew I should have...........
Now.........the Ruger was shot, utilizing 38 wadcutters (yawn) and they woked flawlesly of course.. He (Steve) shot the 357 Mags and was quite surprised in the differnece of the loads. LOL.....shocked him..:image035: he was hitting the bull..........in real good shape and shot the heck out of the gun...:banana:
The Sig 226 shot flawlessly, with no FTF or FTE in 200 rounds........groups were minimal with the widest span being 3 inches at 50 ft..typical for the Sig.. but exceptional weapon to say the least..:yup:
Steve shot the Kimber Pro CDP........and yes...........loved it to say the least........NO FTF or FTE..........he mentioned that the grips could be slightly smoother due to them biting his palms.........suggested rubber or gripper grips to accomodate the recoil of the God Dot ammo..BTW.......I sat back, listened to his remarks from his perspective (he's 15 yrs old) Gave me GOOD input for somebody his age.........he also shoots the heck outts all my stuff........so he's well versed in weapons for his age :hand10:
He also shot the Glock 29 and K&K USP Compact 10MM and 40 S&W respectively..
Out of everything he shot...........the Sig and Kimber impresesed him the most......witht he HK USP and finally the Glock bringing up the rear........(the Glock bit into his hands) From his perspective....the Glock's grip frame is slightly awkward but the sig feels at home in his hands along with the Kimber..The Ruger rode up on his hands and was a bit uncomfy in 357 mag LOL but he shot it :image035:
I wanted to give you a report, based on another Shooter's perspective, and not my own.....Thus, and unbiased opinion, especially from the younger voices coming through the ranks!
FIRST........I HATE that WALTHER P22...........I would suggest to NEVER buy one.. My Son Steve, shot his Walther tonight (the one I bought him for Christmas) The gun is a real POS...:rant: ...I hate to say bad things BUT out of 50 rounds of Rem yellow jackets............25 were FTF or FTE..:rant: NOT a good thing........we tried CCI........and the same thing happened........Bringing it back and throwing it at em..:rant: . I'm gonna get him a Ruger MKII K512 like i knew I should have...........
Now.........the Ruger was shot, utilizing 38 wadcutters (yawn) and they woked flawlesly of course.. He (Steve) shot the 357 Mags and was quite surprised in the differnece of the loads. LOL.....shocked him..:image035: he was hitting the bull..........in real good shape and shot the heck out of the gun...:banana:
The Sig 226 shot flawlessly, with no FTF or FTE in 200 rounds........groups were minimal with the widest span being 3 inches at 50 ft..typical for the Sig.. but exceptional weapon to say the least..:yup:
Steve shot the Kimber Pro CDP........and yes...........loved it to say the least........NO FTF or FTE..........he mentioned that the grips could be slightly smoother due to them biting his palms.........suggested rubber or gripper grips to accomodate the recoil of the God Dot ammo..BTW.......I sat back, listened to his remarks from his perspective (he's 15 yrs old) Gave me GOOD input for somebody his age.........he also shoots the heck outts all my stuff........so he's well versed in weapons for his age :hand10:
He also shot the Glock 29 and K&K USP Compact 10MM and 40 S&W respectively..
Out of everything he shot...........the Sig and Kimber impresesed him the most......witht he HK USP and finally the Glock bringing up the rear........(the Glock bit into his hands) From his perspective....the Glock's grip frame is slightly awkward but the sig feels at home in his hands along with the Kimber..The Ruger rode up on his hands and was a bit uncomfy in 357 mag LOL but he shot it :image035:
I wanted to give you a report, based on another Shooter's perspective, and not my own.....Thus, and unbiased opinion, especially from the younger voices coming through the ranks!
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
Joined
·
3,117 Posts
I wish my Dad had been that involved in handgunning when I was 15! He had a cheapie SA .22 but that's all. You're saving him a TON of money in trial and error purchases, trust me! LOL
Great to see the next generation of shooters coming along so well. I wonder how many folks he'll be able to interest in the shooting sports. ;-)
Jack
Great to see the next generation of shooters coming along so well. I wonder how many folks he'll be able to interest in the shooting sports. ;-)
Jack
Joined
·
1,866 Posts
too bad about the Walther, mine works very well unless dirty but I look at it like this, it's a trainer and you can train a young person on clearing jams, etc. Beyond training and plinking can's it's not really worth much for any use. I have a limited edition with both barrel sizes, a case, etc. I'm thinking of traking it in towards another weapon but the main gun shop in my area is a total rip off on any trade-in. They have a huge attitude becasue they know they're about the only show in Cape Girardeau Missouri that has any selection. I agree that's worth something but they think it's gold!
I've always felt bad trading guns though, felt like I was giving up a child or something :redface:
Still, I'd love to get an SA Micro Compact in .40 and this trade could help a little....
God Bless
Gideon
I've always felt bad trading guns though, felt like I was giving up a child or something :redface:
Still, I'd love to get an SA Micro Compact in .40 and this trade could help a little....
God Bless
Gideon
Joined
·
25,596 Posts
Great stuff Bob! Your boy is getting to experience many platforms, which is good.
Not that surprised re the Walther - I honestly have yet to hear many glowing reports on those, tho supposedly the later ones had ironed out the feed issues. yep - a MkII or even, consider the 22/45 - which IMO has better grip angle and the controls are more conventional.
The 226 - flawless - well of course :smile: Nice eh - and no wonder Steve liked it. I put a bunch of ammo thru mine today - since I realized what had been the prob with it weeks ago - it is totally on song and rockin'.
Good session it'd seem. Good job.
Not that surprised re the Walther - I honestly have yet to hear many glowing reports on those, tho supposedly the later ones had ironed out the feed issues. yep - a MkII or even, consider the 22/45 - which IMO has better grip angle and the controls are more conventional.
The 226 - flawless - well of course :smile: Nice eh - and no wonder Steve liked it. I put a bunch of ammo thru mine today - since I realized what had been the prob with it weeks ago - it is totally on song and rockin'.
Good session it'd seem. Good job.
Joined
·
10,366 Posts
Guys.....I'm bringing the Walther back to the store tomorrow (Sunday) gonna try to work out the bugs ........but either way........I have placed a LNIB Browing Buckmark 5.5 inch BBL on hold............for 250.00 (really not a good deal, but I wanna see how Steve (my Son) likes the feel of the gun..
Secondly.........I also have a ANIB Ruger KMK512 22 on hold too.......stainless with all accys and boxes...........they retail at the store for 389.95.........this one's out for 265.00........I'm also considering the 22/45 due to Chris' input and opinion on the weapon, as it's similar to the 1911 grip angle....then my discount applies to both guns..making them even more afforable........should I move on em.
How do you feel about either one of the above guns? (I prefer the Ruger as it's more expensive and they've always worked)
Any input is MOST appreciated.. Thanks
Bob
Secondly.........I also have a ANIB Ruger KMK512 22 on hold too.......stainless with all accys and boxes...........they retail at the store for 389.95.........this one's out for 265.00........I'm also considering the 22/45 due to Chris' input and opinion on the weapon, as it's similar to the 1911 grip angle....then my discount applies to both guns..making them even more afforable........should I move on em.
How do you feel about either one of the above guns? (I prefer the Ruger as it's more expensive and they've always worked)
Any input is MOST appreciated.. Thanks
Bob
Joined
·
25,596 Posts
Bob - a guy I shoot pins with got himself and his wife a Buckmark and now they are well shot, in they seem first class. So in reliability stakes a very reasonable choice.
I do think tho in the longevity stakes the Ruger will keep on runnin' longer.
One point with the Ruger - meaning here the 22/45 - I did change the extractor to a Volquartsen - the slightly sharper and better angled item, which cured my occasional extract hiccups - so I think it is a worthwhile addition. Otherwise Ruger takes the choice for me.
Oh - small point - the slide release and safety ''buttons'' on the Ruger are very sharp edged - quite manageable but an irritation which, if I did a total strip down, I would put to rights.
Think you've seen this Bob - but my Ruger with a Bushnell Trophy red dot on So-Low mounts and added comp. ..............
![]()
I do think tho in the longevity stakes the Ruger will keep on runnin' longer.
One point with the Ruger - meaning here the 22/45 - I did change the extractor to a Volquartsen - the slightly sharper and better angled item, which cured my occasional extract hiccups - so I think it is a worthwhile addition. Otherwise Ruger takes the choice for me.
Oh - small point - the slide release and safety ''buttons'' on the Ruger are very sharp edged - quite manageable but an irritation which, if I did a total strip down, I would put to rights.
Think you've seen this Bob - but my Ruger with a Bushnell Trophy red dot on So-Low mounts and added comp. ..............
Joined
·
10,366 Posts
That's a VERY COOL setup ya got Chris!! Might just go that way as you'r picture of the 22/45........my Son (Steve ) has to agree on it, as it's going to be his gun..
Hopfully, I'm starting him out the right way...........and so far, I'm seeing him take on some really good responsibility on safe handling and shooting procedures.
Ohh BYW........he went to the Store with me, and was handling the in-stock M1 Garands, (he's in Jr ROTC right now) and loves the darn things......I can see the DCM in his future
Hopfully, I'm starting him out the right way...........and so far, I'm seeing him take on some really good responsibility on safe handling and shooting procedures.
Ohh BYW........he went to the Store with me, and was handling the in-stock M1 Garands, (he's in Jr ROTC right now) and loves the darn things......I can see the DCM in his future
Joined
·
90 Posts
Good job Bob. Keep up the good work with this young man.
Joined
·
10,366 Posts
I know what you mean Chris..<sigh>. :yup: Thanks for the words of encoragment Ram :biggrin2:P95Carry said:
The kid is in Drill Team with the Jr ROTC....While at the Store....he was doing the Manual-of-Arms with the Garand........asked me if he could have one..:biggrin2:
He also saw those CETMEs on the rack ..425.00 looked VERY apealing to him, over the 750.00-900.00 price range of the M1s.. He DID say that he'd rather have the M1..cuz.....in his words.. "It's another peice of History.. and they shoot REAL GOOD" Now......I never really talked much about that rifle......so he must have been checkin out the lure and history on them..:biggrin2:
Well, I told him, "you have money from this Walther coming to you, and you can use that $$ to place on one of the other weapons" sooo the choice is his..
I told him he can always get a 22........but the M1s and Cetme are a better investment cuz they're never goin down in price.. especially when the parts on the Cetmes dry up and the price starts to climb:yup:
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
