Defensive Carry banner

1 - 20 of 22 Posts

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,625 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I grabbed my LCR last night and decided to have a dry fire session with it with the hopes of maybe someday get proficient enough to get it back in my rotation. I retired it from my carry options due to it being "different" and lower capacity than any of my semi autos.

Well last night did nothing to add to my confidence. It actually eroded it further. The trigger is completely different from my semis. I'm used to a short reset and the "glass break" feel of my Glocks. In comparison my LCR required 1 inch of long pull and a full depress to reset. I kept messing up on my trigger pulls when I did rapid fire drills.

Working either speed strips (which are a pain to do right when done fast or under stress) or speed loaders (a lot better) is trumped by just dropping a mag and replacing it.

At the range I always struggled with the sight picture difference (having to aim lower with the LCR due to muzzle rise) and general recoil behavior that are subtly but yet significantly different from semis.

So I guess in short, my muscle memory is dedicate to semis and forcing myself to get into revolvers proves to me a huge struggle.

How many of you carry revolvers and semis in your rotation? Do you have similar issues as I've been having? How are you able to work with two distinctly different sets of muscle memories for two very different types of guns?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,335 Posts
I have been shooting snubs for so long have no problem going back an forth. Carry either SP101 2.4 or Mod 60 or 642 90% of time but have no prob going to a shield. One thing I do have action jobs done on all revolvers either by Teddy Jacobson at Actions by T or Gemini Custom. Huge difference really makes them a joy to shoot. I always reload from speed strips at the range you would be amazed how fast you get.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
24,512 Posts
I carry both,the snubby not often, and have never had a problem with it. Of course I learned to shoot with a revolver, so that may have something to do with it.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,625 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
I think I've seen revolver guys transition to semis easier than the opposite. I started with semis and its hard to get into revolvers.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,628 Posts
I switch often from a 38 to my SR9C depending on dress and perceived need.
Not problem shooting either.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,276 Posts
What purpose does it serve in your 'carry rotation'?
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,625 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
What purpose does it serve in your 'carry rotation'?
Right now it isn't even in it. At most it'll serve as a bug. I don't trust myself to switch to a revolver as my main piece. As long as I don't have to reload it I'm ok with it
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,261 Posts
I have carried both but the Rossi .38 spl that I had was stolen. I have not replaced it, yet.

My wife (who also carries) had a Ruger LCP (sadly it to, stolen) then wanted a revolver so I got her the LCR .357 magnum. She is carrying it now.

I have a new Taurus 9mm and the S&W Bodyguard .380 but would simply love to have an LCR like what my wife has. I want to be diverse in my carry firearms and just not rely on one kind.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,625 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
I had hopes of being a "generalist" too but I was super surprised how my muscle memory pushed me automatically to Glock mode. I fumbled badly with the trigger reset on the LCR. As most of you know, the trigger has to be depressed all the way with revolvers in order to reset. I kept half releasing my trigger expecting a reset during my drills. In a real life fight I would have been screwed.

I know I can overcome all of this with practice but I'm more interested in getting really good with one platform than have to flip the switch between them. Revolvers and semis (and even DAO, SAO, DA/SA) are too different.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,157 Posts
I grabbed my LCR last night and decided to have a dry fire session with it with the hopes of maybe someday get proficient enough to get it back in my rotation. I retired it from my carry options due to it being "different" and lower capacity than any of my semi autos.

Well last night did nothing to add to my confidence. It actually eroded it further. The trigger is completely different from my semis. I'm used to a short reset and the "glass break" feel of my Glocks. In comparison my LCR required 1 inch of long pull and a full depress to reset. I kept messing up on my trigger pulls when I did rapid fire drills.

Working either speed strips (which are a pain to do right when done fast or under stress) or speed loaders (a lot better) is trumped by just dropping a mag and replacing it.

At the range I always struggled with the sight picture difference (having to aim lower with the LCR due to muzzle rise) and general recoil behavior that are subtly but yet significantly different from semis.

So I guess in short, my muscle memory is dedicate to semis and forcing myself to get into revolvers proves to me a huge struggle.

How many of you carry revolvers and semis in your rotation? Do you have similar issues as I've been having? How are you able to work with two distinctly different sets of muscle memories for two very different types of guns?
My belief is to be consistent with the weapon system that you carry. Changing things up on a new carrier IMO can be dangerous. Even with an experience carrier it can be dangerous. That being said, How many reps do you have with your draw and presentation? If less than 5000 you still need a lot of work. This is not to criticize what you are doing, it is to put things into perspective. If you are going to switch weapons, you have to know how to use each and every one of them, and yes, that takes at least 5000 reps with each.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DetChris

·
Registered
Joined
·
697 Posts
It does take some work to be proficient with both and interchange, but it is possible. I guess one of the reasons I'm fine with going back and forth is that my two main small carry guns are a LCR .38 and a Kahr CM9. Both have a DAO trigger so that takes some of the issue out.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,131 Posts
i regularly switch between my Sig DA/SA pistols and three S&W DA/SA revolvers. the Sigs are a P-239/9mm, a P-229/.357SIG, and a P-220/.45. the wheel guns are an S&W 66/2.5", a 625/3", and a 625/4". there is also a Kahr CM-9 which gets thrown into the rotation as a pocket carry gun.

what all these guns have in common is that all are "point and shoot" guns without safeties, and all have a long DA pull for the first shot. the Sigs, of course, will transition to the shorter SA pull for all subsequent shots, (and i have no problems making the DA to SA switch), while the S&W's and the Kahr will continue to have the longer DA pull.

prior to the Kahr, i used an S&W 642 as my pocket gun, but i shot it so much worse than the others, including the Kahr, that i have retired it from the carry rotation.


to the OP: based on an earlier post about people with snubby revolvers, while there are folks who can shoot them very well, there are others, like me, who have trouble with the short sight radius, light weight, and longer trigger pulls of the alloy and polymer snubs. perhaps if you try a steel, 3-4 inch barrel revolver, you'll come closer to what you can do with your Glocks.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
8,832 Posts
You can learn to shoot both very well with practice.

I have practiced a lot with both. For point shooting, I can shoot my CZ 75D PCR slightly more accurately than my J-frame revolvers, a fact which I attribute to the DA/SA trigger and pull weight. However, for my L-frame 686's it's a toss up, and the 686 has a long DA pull.

For aimed shooting I am simply not as accurate with the short barreled snubbies due to the short sight radius. But with snubbies I am not going for groups, and most of my practice is point shooting with *rough* sight alignment. In other words, I'm trying to place rounds in the "pie plate" at 5 - 7 yards as rapidly as possible.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,625 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
My belief is to be consistent with the weapon system that you carry. Changing things up on a new carrier IMO can be dangerous. Even with an experience carrier it can be dangerous. That being said, How many reps do you have with your draw and presentation? If less than 5000 you still need a lot of work. This is not to criticize what you are doing, it is to put things into perspective. If you are going to switch weapons, you have to know how to use each and every one of them, and yes, that takes at least 5000 reps with each.
HB if anything it has cemented my decision to stick to just Glocks for carry. I will continue to shoot and own different platforms because that's just plain fun. But carrying = life and death. I'll only trust one brand and one platform for that.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,157 Posts
HB if anything it has cemented my decision to stick to just Glocks for carry. I will continue to shoot and own different platforms because that's just plain fun. But carrying = life and death. I'll only trust one brand and one platform for that.
For you I think that is a good choice, Keeping with the same manual of arms. That being said, there are people that can do it. Like I said before, it takes a bit of training to master all.....:image035:
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
5,171 Posts
Everyone has made some good points, and it sounds like you have it figured out. If it ain't broke, why fix it? If the Glock is working for you, carry that and keep the snubbie in a backup role.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
5,611 Posts
To each their own..... I carry a g22, an sr40c, and an LCR. Different platforms each but they all function the same. Pull trigger go bang. I don't use safeties so they all work the same. The LCR thas a fantastic trigger for a dao trigger...... it takes practice due to its lack lf a reset.

I agree if its not comfortable for you to operatet then you should stick to what works for you

Sent from my DROID4 using Tapatalk 2
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
676 Posts
I go back and forth. In warm months I carry a S&W 642 .38. In cool months I carry a Glock 21SF .45. I practice with both and have no problems switching. Although obviously I don't have the ammo capacity with the .38 I feel adequately protected with 5 rounds of +P.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
329 Posts
Do what works for you. When I started shooting in the early 80's, the department where I did my training had us shooting revolvers, and I was terrible with them.

I started shooting a Ruger mkI and had instant improvement. My shooting coach put a Colt Gold Cup built by Jim Clark in my hand, and I became a 1911 guy for life.The gold Cup was the first gun I owned.

I briefly had a Baretta 92 (hated it, only gun I have ever sold) in the late 80's and an HK P7 and Browning Hi Power built by Novaks and more than a dozen 1911 variants.

Two years ago I bought a Ruger 'Birds Head' Vaquero because I fell in love with the looks of it. The first revolver I even remotely considered buying.

Last year a neighbor of mine gave me an old S&W Airwieght J frame. Her son (a convicted felon) was moving back home and she caught him looking for it. At the time I had no intention of ever carrying it, and figured I would sell it and give her the money. Well, I put a Hogue rubber grip on it and took it to the range with me, and found out the two of us get along really well. I found it to be surprisingly accurate and easy to shoot. I got a lot of time in with it last summer and bought a comfortable IWB holster for it and carry it when I want a light, low profile gun. It has replaced my LC9 for that role.

I have also shot an LCR, and would buy one in a heartbeat if I had to replace the Smith.

I have also picked up another revolver. A Ruger Alaskan .44 mag. But mostly because I fell in love with the looks of it (like the Vaquero). I carry it in the woods in Northern wisconsin. My GF thinks it's in case of bears (which we see now and then). But mostly it's for armed pot growers who have been in the area the last few years.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
407 Posts
If carrying glocks is what works for you, then by all mean stick with glocks. I think its a good idea to get somewhat proficient with several models of arms, just to have a bit more flexibility. In addition, it has seemed to me that revolvers conceal more easily due to their rounded shape. Either way, carry whatever you are comfortable with and can conceal effectively.
 
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
Top