Defensive Carry banner

1 - 20 of 20 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,631 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Anyone have any experience or own a Rock Island 1911? Found one for sale has had some custom work done on it slide job, trigger and bobbed. Trigger is crisp, fit it tight, locks up solidly seems like a decent gun. Seems like a solid well made gun but know nothing about Rock Island guns, the quality of their parts workmanship or customer service so any input would be appreciated. Thanks.
 

·
Administrator
Joined
·
143,739 Posts
How good of a price can you get it for? Some of the internal parts may have been upgraded already in that gun.

The frames are high quality castings rather than being forged. Not really a problem with a firearm in .45 acp.

The slides are forged from bar stock.

The barrel is hammer forged.

MIM (metal injected molded) parts would be:

slide stop - I would absolutely swap this part out for a better quality part like an Ed Brown. :yup:

plunger tube - not a problem in MIM

sear - 50/50 - I would probably buy pre-mated high quality hammer and sear combo.

disconnector
- Not usually a problem but, I would install a COLT factory disconnector

ejector - usually not a problem.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Obviously now I need to add Hammer & Thumb Safety to the M.I.M. list.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
938 Posts
I really like mine. The grip safety spring on mine lost tension after a few hundred rounds, so I attempted to take it apart to tweak that. Well, the cast ambi thumb safety broke during disassembly, so I just went and ordered a Wilson thumb safety and Bulletproof sear spring. I dropped it off at my hometown LGS to have the safety fitted a few weeks ago, but I haven't been home to see it since then.

I'm a poor college student, so I bought mine with the intent of gradually building something I want from a solid base gun, so this issue really didn't bother me since the ambi safety was going to be the first thing to go.
 

·
Administrator
Joined
·
143,739 Posts
Many gun folks used to buy them for the slide and frame AKA as a base gun to do a custom build.

For awhile there some of the RI barrels were short chambered and/or tight chambered and that caused some function issues in the past with some ammo brands but, I believe that is no longer the case.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,631 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
How good of a price can you get it for?
Asking $450 probably get it for $400. Thanks for the input. My dilemma is I have been planning on a XDS. Not sure if I can get both.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
2,609 Posts
Will this be your first 1911?(if not you can stop reading this)

I ask because it will definitely not be your only 1911.

1911's are like tattoos; Don't get the first one if you can't afford the rest of the collection!

At $400.00 I'd pop on the RIA myself but I'm not a fan of the XD pistols to start.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15 Posts
I have a Rock Island 45cal that I have been shooting for almost 10 years. Only thing I have changed is the stock grips to a Hogue grip. Now, I haven't shot 10 thousands rounds through it but, its had it's fair share plus a few. I break it down, examine the wearing parts(nothing replaced to date), oil it up with CLP, re-assemble it, service check it, load it and holster it. Never had a problem with it!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
97 Posts
I was in the same boat about 3 weeks ago, I bought the xds but I plan on buying the RIA
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
606 Posts
I've had 2 RIA 1911's, the full size 1911-A1-FS and the compact 1911-A1-CS. Both were completely reliable out of the box. I had my misgivings at first, but they were quickly put to bed. Both were under $500. You can't beat that. The only complaint I had was with the finish. A little rough around the edges, but what do you expect for under $500? I say RIA 1911's are a steal. You can't go wrong.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aceoky

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,631 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
Want to thank everyone for their replies. You have me sold, I got the XDs and set aside the cash for the Rock Island. Unfortunately it appears that I snoozed. At least the seller is not getting back to me. But now I know, if another comes up I will not hesitate. Again thank you for your input gentlemen, much appreciated.

Will this be your first 1911?(if not you can stop reading this)

I ask because it will definitely not be your only 1911.

1911's are like tattoos; Don't get the first one if you can't afford the rest of the collection!

At $400.00 I'd pop on the RIA myself but I'm not a fan of the XD pistols to start.
No, got my first, way back in 1973, from my dad. It was his WWII/Korean war issue 1911.That thing rattled and at twenty feet shot feet off POA , seriously. Feet not inches. Never imagining that 1911 gunsmiths could produce the reliable accurate 1911 we have today. To young to appreciate what an incredible piece of American and family history I had. I sold it. That is one few thing I truly regret having done in my life.

I love my XD's. Best carry guns I have ever had. Can not wait until I put this little XDs through its paces and have a holster made so I can make it my new EDC. Especially with summer looming just around the corner. With the extended mag 7 rounds of .45 HST in what is nearly a pocket pistol whats not to love?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
938 Posts
Mine has been in the shop longer than I've had it. The MIM safety snapped off, which I didn't really mind since I hated the one that came with it, the gun loosened up so much that the gun functioned without the grip safety being held, and the other day when I was checking function after installing a new safety and sear spring, the hammer broke off! That really annoyed me. It is on its way back to Nevada for a month while they deal with that. They're doing right by me, and I really like the pistol when it works, but I will steer clear of any additional RIA products from now on unless I wanted a gun for a donor frame where I replaced everything else.

IMG_1748.jpg IMG_1747.jpg
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,524 Posts
As I understand there varying degrees of quality on the RIAs. I think however if you get a good one that performs well from the start you are probably good to go. At $400.00 I would not hesitate to try one and have low expectations. If it works out then all is good.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,908 Posts
I carry one daily , and would buy another the Customer service is very, very good, lifetime warranty regardless of if you're the buyer-

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
464 Posts
My Govt Model took 500+ rounds--mostly my low-velocity, lead truncated cone handloads--to break in, like the manual says to expect, and hasn't had any malfunction in perhaps 500 rounds since then. Put on a pair of checkered grips and a curved mainspring housing, because that feels like the GI guns I was used to, but have made no other mods or repairs.

Got a used Compact from a guy who declared it trouble free, and my first several hundred rounds indeed have been flawless.

I dabble with lots of guns and loads, and don't torture-test them like competition guns may get used. To date, I am completely satisfied & I use them in my SD/HD rotation with confidence.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
789 Posts
I have a RI compact. I haven't had any problems with it, however, it is really heavy for a compact. My wife likes it when we shoot because the weight holds down the recoil.
 
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Top