Defensive Carry banner
1 - 20 of 38 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
31 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I've had this awesome 1911 since February this year with no issues what so ever until now. I have fired over 900 rounds through this firearm. Today, I was firing stock, Federal 45 acp, from Walmart.

Firearm link
Products

:frown:Barrel lug sheared off of the barrel. I sent ATI an email with pictures so I can start the process of sending it back to them, etc.

This has been my primary EDC. Now I am back to my G19. I hope the replacement process doesn't take too long. Material property
Shotgun Trigger Bumper Revolver
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,865 Posts
I am so sorry to hear that. Hopefully they will take care of the problem. Please let us know what they say and how good or bad the CS is.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,865 Posts
Wow. That failure after only 900? Hope they take care of you.
Yup, that does not look good at all. It is a pity because they are good looking firearms and the price is not bad. Lets hope that they have a good CS and that the problem was only with that specific gun and not with all of them.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,095 Posts
I did pick up on your "back to my G19" comment. I started by carrying a Kimber Ultra CDP II, and my wife an Ultra Aegis II. After a few FTFs and stovepipes, I had my ccw set up by a 1911 master pistolsmith. Yet, I eventually gave in to the Dark Side(tm), bought a G19, and stopped worrying about my EDC.


I am not a gun "hobbiest", and just need something that will go bang should I ever need it. I also just bought my first Harley (yeah, yeah, I know - middle-aged guy with first Harley...), and my concealed carry weapon will have to keep up with me in all kinds of conditions now. The Kimber is sure pretty sitting in the safe. The Glock rides along.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,100 Posts
many of us, me included poke fun at the glock...n
but for an out-of-the-box gun; its one i would trust.

that said, there are a great many gun makers today and what they made last year, heck--even last month, may not be the same in all areas. thus quality and consistency is rather hit or miss.
for many years i have taken my loops ( and other items) to the gun store. with the 6x or 10x i look at the frame and places of stress. many the time i have passed on a used, even a new, gun cause of indicators. some stress fractures are present under power in a great many used guns , irregardless of price; yet are not a reason to pass on the gun. a gap at the bbl link ( i have seen it a number of times--if there are no odd marks on the frame /slide contact area) sure means the gun needs a new bbl at the very least. but why did it happen?
perhaps the gun was shot with a tired old slide spring, lots of hot ammo and not a strong enough spring. sometimes a 5 cent plastic slide shock absorber is all that was needed. some tines it was a bad weld at the factory. or the wrong size link was fit, too short--though the gun ran. it was not locking up right.
with a newer bbl, check that the link is the proper length and for accuracy that the bushing ID/bbl's OD and its OD to frame are fitted.
good luck.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
21,646 Posts
This is the very thing I feared when I ruled out the ATI and RIA from my 1911 choices. It's not that they are inherrently bad guns, but for a price that cheap, I couldn't help but wonder where the corners were cut to allow that. Now I know.

While the lower cost is great, it's my belief that sometimes it's better to save a little more and invest in a product with a company that has a history and a predictable quality.

In any event, sorry about that breakage, but I would have trusted the Glock over an ATI any day and twice on Sunday.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,865 Posts
This is the very thing I feared when I ruled out the ATI and RIA from my 1911 choices. It's not that they are inherrently bad guns, but for a price that cheap, I couldn't help but wonder where the corners were cut to allow that. Now I know.

While the lower cost is great, it's my belief that sometimes it's better to save a little more and invest in a product with a company that has a history and a predictable quality.

In any event, sorry about that breakage, but I would have trusted the Glock over an ATI any day and twice on Sunday.
Unfortunately I think you are right; usually you get what you pay for. Low cost it great and that something is expensive does not necessarily imply that it is good, but my experience tells me that "cheap" can be very expensive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JD

·
Registered
Joined
·
49 Posts
Why on earth do the Glock lovers always contaminate threads reporting malfunctions of other manufacturers weapons. I don't own an ATI so I don't have a dog in this fight. I would never jump to any conclusions regarding ATI quality based on this failure. All manufacturers can and will have "duds" over time. If you don't believe that the almighty GLOCK can have problems, simply Google === Glock broke and see what pops up.

OP, I'd be willing to bet you are taken care of by the maker of that weapon. Thanks for posting.
 

·
Moderator
Joined
·
8,501 Posts
Why on earth do the Glock lovers always contaminate threads reporting malfunctions of other manufacturers weapons. I don't own an ATI so I don't have a dog in this fight. I would never jump to any conclusions regarding ATI quality based on this failure. All manufacturers can and will have "duds" over time. If you don't believe that the almighty GLOCK can have problems, simply Google === Glock broke and see what pops up.

OP, I'd be willing to bet you are taken care of by the maker of that weapon. Thanks for posting.
It might be because the OP referred to the fact that he will be carrying a Glock until his pistol s fixed. If you can't see the line of thinking here I'll explain it a little better. The OP bought a low end 1911 and it broke. Now he carries a Glock because it's still working.

I'm guessing, but I'd bet that the OP's broken 1911 costs more than his working Glock. Now you may or may not like Glocks but there is some irony in this situation and people are bound to comment on it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
304 Posts
When I first read this I thought it said "STI" and I didn't understand why you guys were saying it was a cheap 1911... Now I get it... ATI... :blink:

I was going to get a 1911 for my carry but opted for the G19.... I don't think it is a downgrade as the OP seemed to imply. :smile:

Good Luck with the repairs
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
Ati titan ss 45 1911

I purchased an ATI Titan SS 45 a few months ago from the Boise Gun Company thinking I would save a few bucks. I paid $600. A big mistake. To begin this pistold came in a clear plastic bag, without a case, only one magazine and no operating/maintenace manual. I had to flitz and use jewerls sandpaper to smooth out all of the CNC sharp edges. I was actually cut by a sharp edge while breaking the pistol down prior to doing that. I had to buff the feed ramp to get the pistol to feed HP ammo. Also the factory magazine was trash. I had many fail to feed issues until I swapped out to using one of my SF and Kimber mags. Also the grips are an odd color and made of a very soft wood. Already showing signs of wear. Wait until you try and remove the rod/spring. A real chore. The pistol does shoot nicely since I overcame the problems. A pistol smith will charge you hundreds to do what you can do yourself with a little instruction. Still needs grips and a proper mag. Don't waste your money. Buy a quality USA made gun. I just bought an EMP SF 9mm. Looks like a mini 1911. Perfect right out of the box. USA made right the first time. PI guns are cheap for a reason.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
20,257 Posts
A guy I shoot steel with had the exact same thing happen to him on his STI .38 Super game gun - after about 30,000 rounds.

I guess ATI had to cut costs somewhere.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,377 Posts
It could be a random failure though. Perhaps the OP just got one that slipped through QC? It is funny how everyone jumps on the bandwagon of "cheap crap" and so on. I wonder if they have the same mindset on other products in their lives. For instance a car. If your car has a mechanical failure do you automatically say "well, I gotta go buy a new one cause this is crap".

Sure, a Glock will go bang and is tough. So is an M&P, so is a revolver. Who cares? Apparently so did his ATI till it broke. Crap happens with mechanical things. And yes, I have even seen a Glock malfunction. Whether 900 or 9000 rounds, a failure is a failure. We can only do so much to ensure our chosen weapons are reliable. In the end, crap happens, and sometimes at the worst possible moment.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,465 Posts
I'm sorry for the OP's problem, but I see no need to make a blanket assessment based on one incident.

My Titan FX45 took some break-in and fluffing/buffing, but I expect that from a $450 1911. It runs great now.

But really, the lesson that I learned is that I don't like short-barreled 1911's. I'd much rater learn that on a ATI price tag vs. a Colt price tag. :yup:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,670 Posts
At least it happened while practicing, not when you really needed it to protect yourself. At least this time, you will get a chance to repair it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
887 Posts
It could be a random failure though. Perhaps the OP just got one that slipped through QC? It is funny how everyone jumps on the bandwagon of "cheap crap" and so on. I wonder if they have the same mindset on other products in their lives. For instance a car. If your car has a mechanical failure do you automatically say "well, I gotta go buy a new one cause this is crap".

Sure, a Glock will go bang and is tough. So is an M&P, so is a revolver. Who cares? Apparently so did his ATI till it broke. Crap happens with mechanical things. And yes, I have even seen a Glock malfunction. Whether 900 or 9000 rounds, a failure is a failure. We can only do so much to ensure our chosen weapons are reliable. In the end, crap happens, and sometimes at the worst possible moment.
Two out of the three glocks I've personally shot have malfunctioned. One was my Dad's gen2 G17, which hadn't been cleaned in about 12 years. Fired one mag and started stove piping. Cleaned it and it ran fine. The other is a friends G19 that had a random stovepipe during his initial 500 rounds. No problems since. My G21 is the one that hasn't malfunctioned yet. Runs like a swiss watch, but I do keep it meticulously clean.

As far as low end 1911's, I can attest to the quality being lower. Sure they'll run fine for most people, but the parts ARE lower quality. I had a High Standard Crusader (Armscor, same as RIA) that never had a single malfunction, but started kicking brass into my face. Broke it down and the ejector was horribly bent. Sent it back for repair and they said it was unfixable, offered me a new gun 3 months later. When I picked out the gun I wanted, they shipped mine back to me. All they had done was bend the ejector back straight. One magazine and it was bent again. Traded it in that afternoon and never looked back.

Bottom line, ANY gun can malfunction. Even the almighty Glock. Granted the malfunctions I've experienced haven't been as bad as what the OP had, but I'm sure there's a number of glocks that sheared, broken, or bent something they shouldn't have.
 
1 - 20 of 38 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top