Defensive Carry banner

1 - 20 of 25 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
454 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I have been thinking alot about a Sig lately. The P250 might be in my price range. Are they a good quality pistol? Are they on par with a 220 or the other SIGs? How do they rate with a Glock or an XD? Thanks for the feedback. Robbie
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
134 Posts
I have been thinking alot about a Sig lately. The P250 might be in my price range. Are they a good quality pistol? Are they on par with a 220 or the other SIGs? How do they rate with a Glock or an XD? Thanks for the feedback. Robbie
I think most of the Sig world has been kind of underwhelmed by the P250. This could be poor marketing by Sig or it could be because the so-called modularity of the gun hasn't really proven it's practicality.

That's not to say it isn't a quality firearm. Anything with Sig on it is worthy of consideration. IMO it is not on a par with the classic Sigs: P220,226,229, etc. It is as least as well made as the Glocks and Xds but has a completely different trigger feel being DAO and not striker fired.

If I were in the market for my first Sig I would take a hard look at the SigPro 2022. It is polymer framed and has high capacity mags available in 9mm, 357sig, and 40 s&w. It is also available from Bud's for about $450 with night sites and two mags. Great deal. And it's a Sig.

Look around on SIGforum for more info.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
136 Posts
I've been looking very hard at the P250 as well, including reading the whole 107 page thread on SigForum, and here's what I've found:

They had early production problems with a batch of extractors, some 9mm magazines, and some of the springs (recoil and trigger system) not being up to snuff. That was 2 years ago, and it's taken a while to get it all sorted out, but it finally seems to be. These problems led to a lot of early FTF (light primer strikes), and FTE. Sig customer service has fixed all the problems without admitting any of them were widespread.

The latest guns produced seem to be problem free. Compact and full sizes are available, the subcompacts aren't yet. Conversion kits seem to be hitting the market in a trickle, and your best bet is ordering direct from Sig for them (be willing to wait a month or six).

Overall, the marketing really preceded the company's ability to meet supply/demand by a good year or two, so if you want one for the gun it is they're good to go, but if you want it for the gun you can turn it into, better to wait a few years and let the supply chain catch up to the idea.

Keep in mind, this is all internet hearsay, and I still haven't been able to find one to hold and fire...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
22,908 Posts
I really don't think they equal a classic Sig pistol, and I think Glock is still king of the polymer pistols.
Is it a good gun? yeah. But there is better.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,972 Posts
Get a Glock
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,078 Posts
I just acquired a SIG Pro 2022 (it was a trade for a Glock that I didn't much care for) and am very happy with it. They can be had for $480-$500 right now, and IIRC are what the P250 will/is replacing. I've not really heard much about the P250 to be honest.



SIG Pro - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
307 Posts
I really don't think they equal a classic Sig pistol, and I think Glock is still king of the polymer pistols.
Is it a good gun? yeah. But there is better.
Wow this is a suprize coming from you...... didddnnnt see that coming
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
50,603 Posts
I'd go with a Glock...but then Glock is my EDC...:ziplip::22a:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,421 Posts
JMO, Sig's are top shelf firearms, they easily rank at or above the Glocks and XDs IMO. You can't go wrong with any of the pistols you mentioned. I'd say try to rent one of each at your gun range and put some rounds down range to get a good feel for each. Go with the one that you feel more comfortable with and shoot better. The quality of all the one's you mentioned are pretty much equal and it really boils down to personal preference. If I had to choose, I say slight edge to Sig, then Glock. JMO. :bier:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
22,908 Posts
Wow this is a suprize coming from you...... didddnnnt see that coming
Why? I just call 'em as I see them. I like certain models, and certain brands do have more appeal than others, but I'm far from a brand whore.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
112 Posts
i have the sig 229 and the sig 250, got the 229 first so i thought the 250 would be great. it is in no way like the other sigs. shooting it is very much like shooting a nice double action revolver. and you do have to let the trigger reset completely. but for some reason i thought the inter-changeability would be great. that has been a real let down. the value of the fire control ass. is only about 100 bucks, what i am saying is this, i have a sig 250 9mm compact, if i want it to be a sig 250 9mm sub-compact i would only save about 100 bucks over the price of a complete new gun. grips are about 50, slide ass are 350 and mags are 35 to 50. now if you wanted to have a 40 and a 357 sig that would only cost you a barrel, or if you just wanted a differant grip that would be cheap. but then sig came out with camo grips and threaded barrels but would not sell them as parts. that and good luck finding parts. if they wanted this gun to be a hit you would have gone into a gunshop, purchased the fire control group, then picked out your parts. and left a happy person. i bet what happens is somebody in the aftermarket world figures this out and starts making parts. that all said i really love my 229. the 250 was an education.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,416 Posts
I'm not a fan of the P250. I dislike the trigger system and there are many parts and "kits" not available yet to market. So being able to have a .45acp and a 9mm in the same "gun" is not reality yet.

You would however likely be very pleased with a P229 or P220 if you're looking for a SIG. More money but a better trigger system in a proven & reliable package. That's just my opinion of course.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,327 Posts
To answer the OP...I have shot the p250 in 9mm next to a p228 in 9mm. They are not near the fit, finish or shootability of the classic p series pistols. The trigger is long slow and creepy. It is very accurate and I suppose you could get used to it. But in polymer I agree with Sixto...go Glock. Metal framed pistols...I think it would be Sig. Probably why I have a p228 and a G23. LOL
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,020 Posts
I can state that my next gun is going to be a Sig P250 in 45ACP. I have read some phenomenal reviews on it and had excellent feedback from friends that own the gun. I love it's light weight and slightly increased capacity on the 45, too. I have found that in my dry firing the gun (so no BOOM, just a click) the trigger pull is long, smooth and incredibly light and consistent. Exactly what I want in a carry piece. Glocks are too bulky for me, ergonomically speaking. I have owned three and sold them all. I love the modularity of the Sig grips, although I'm not really going to be seeking to swap calibers and frames. The ability to make the grip smaller for my smallish hands is a major "plus" for me. I discovered this in my H&K P30 9mm. While I really like the feel of the H&K 45 I equally dislike the feel of the H&K 45 compact. That gives the Sig P250 the edge there.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,121 Posts
I have praised the Sig 2022 many times. If Sig only made polymer handguns the Pro would be considered top line easily compared to Glock, XD, and other polymers. But Sig's Classic line is what they are most concerned with so the Pro is very much ignored by them. BTW . . . In my opinion the best polymer handgun is H&K.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
882 Posts
I love my P250 in .40. It's the only Sig I own. The P series steel frame Sigs just don't do it for me. I don't care for the DA/SA system, and their DAK trigger is not nearly as smooth and light as the DA trigger on my P250. It's kind of like having a 14 shot revolver. I have the small grip frame and it fits me perfectly, rivaling my M&P compact in ergonomics.

I really like the easy of disassembly, and the modularity makes it easy to really clean the pistol. All of the working parts are easily accessible. All of my semiautos are 40 caliber, so I don't care so much about caliber swapping. I bought the gun as a standalone pistol, not a modular kit, and it has performed very well for me.

I wouldn't say that the P250 will ever replace excellent poly pistols like the Glock or M&P. It's hard to beat the short trigger reset of the striker fired pistols. But for DA hammer fired poly pistols, I think the P250 beats the HK LEM or the Beretta PX4 "C" models in trigger pull weight and smoothness, and ergonomics. (I've shot all 3, and have owned a Beretta C model) My M&P compact gets more carry time than my P250, but there is still a place in my collection of working guns for the excellent P250.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
227 Posts
I have a few traditional Sig's (P220, P229, P6) and a couple of their blowback guns (a P232 and a Mosquito). Love them all dearly.

I also have a few H&K USPc's; (2) in .40 S&W and a .45 ACP.

If I were to purchase another polymer framed weapon it would probably be an H&K P2000 or the new P30. Love my Sig Sauer's just don't want a plastic one.

If Glock and I made a good combination I would have bunch of Glocks. Can't shoot one so I don't want one.

Whatever you decide on just make sure that YOU like it and that YOU can shoot it efficiently.

IOW, if that P250 turns you on and you can shoot it well, stimulate the economy and buy it!

Be Safe

NosaM
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,579 Posts
Hi,

I actually just got a new P250 in 45.acp and all I can say is that it's great gun. I have owned Glock's and still own XD's, but they are just a level lower then a SIG. I get a kick out the the classic SIG owner who moans about this model being polymer and DAO. Let it go, these are great guns too! Not everyone wants to carry at 30 plus ounce gun, but they still want SIG quality.

The DAO is smooth as silk and gives you something Glock's and XD's don't, I call it another chance to fire a round before tapping and racking. Something else that I love about this gun is dry firing. With the way ammo costs these days having the ability to dry fire a weapon without having to rack the slide every time is sweet.

Anyone who is thinking about a 250, I say check it out. They are great guns!
 
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
Top