Defensive Carry banner

1 - 20 of 46 Posts

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
33,731 Posts
Everything you said makes sense. Very nice vid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PhoenixTS and OD*

·
Registered
Joined
·
33,875 Posts
The pistol is designed to be operated with one hand, so which thumb do you think that should be? You're trying hard to make something out of nothing. Besides, every internet expert knows you're supposed to slingshot the slide anyhow.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
33,731 Posts
The pistol is designed to be operated with one hand, so which thumb do you think that should be? You're trying hard to make something out of nothing. Besides, every internet expert knows you're supposed to slingshot the slide anyhow.
One-handed mag changes are tough. Come to think of it, so are revolver reloads.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
19,639 Posts
If I'm going to a two hand hold on the reload, I'll depress the slide release with my left hand thumb after the same hand makes the mag change and comes onto the grip for the 2 hand hold as demonstrated in the vid by the OP.

I came to that reload, slide release method many decades ago just naturally.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,103 Posts
MTM. Method Time Motion. What method achieves the motion in the lead time? My slide release in on the left. I am right handed and the right thumb is best for me. If I were left handed I would use my right index finger because it would be a the easiest and quickest reach over the top of the slide instead of going around the rear with the thumb.. However, I prefer to slingshot the slide because if you fail to connect properly with the slide release you might be unsuccessful in releasing the slide especially of the gun has not been well broken in. No way are you going to fumble when you use the slingshot method. Thumb release might be faster but it is not necessarily surer.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
90 Posts
First off if you only shoot with both hands on gun you may want to use the thumb to release. BUT my findings is IF I have a failure to lock of slide on slide release it is with the release of slide with the thumb. With the slingshot release of slide I can't remember a failure to lock. Failure to lock does not mean failure to feed but rather the slide just not going all the way in and locking. I don't like having to hit the back of the slide to ram it home to be able to pull the trigger. Maybe it's just my guns and they have weak springs. But slingshot release works and thumb does work ALL the time.

If thumb release works for you great but I'll stick to my slingshot release.

But chances are if you are in a fight and you come to slide lock and you are not behind cover, but in a gunfight for your life, your screwed anyway.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,309 Posts
I practice using the offhand thumb, strong hand thumb and weak hand only trigger finger if the gun has a slide stop on one side, offside thumb on the other.

I want to be able to run any weapon with either or both hands.

Mostly, I release the slide with the over the top method.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
501 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
If I were to reload one handed (my support hand is not in play), I would not be inserting the magazine with my support hand and I would resort to a one handed reload. I would therefore not have any issues addressed in the video above.

The pistol is designed to be operated with one hand, so which thumb do you think that should be? You're trying hard to make something out of nothing. Besides, every internet expert knows you're supposed to slingshot the slide anyhow.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
700 Posts
I'm left-handed. Any more I only slingshot. It just universally works on any slide action pistol I might have. For one handed reloads I practice;

Mag drop. Stuff in belt line/pocket/between knees. Insert fresh mag*. Draw with good hand, rack slide off belt, crook of knee, table or whatever piece of cover I might be behind. Get back in fight. ** I really like the Hackathorn sights on my Glock 43 for being able to slingshot my slide off of any handy object.





* I have found this more difficult when left-handed only, I carry extra mag or two off-hand...maybe I should carry one on each side? Need to think about this more and experiment.

** I don't practice this often enough, but have added it and strong hand only / off-hand range time to the mix this past year or so.

---

P.S. I think the only time I would still use the slide release is a 1911. I can still just pick up one of those and run it without thinking...a 1911 is not just merely some old slide action.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
33,875 Posts
If I were to reload one handed (my support hand is not in play), I would not be inserting the magazine with my support hand and I would resort to a one handed reload. I would therefore not have any issues addressed in the video above.
Well, it you wish to convert what I said into meaning using one hand only to insert the magazine and drop the slide, go for it. But you clearly understand the controls are designed to be used with the shooting hand only and not "require" a support hand, seeing as you would now be handling two separate items--gun and magazine.

You asked for comments. I think you're creating a solution for a hypothetical problem. There's more than one way to drop a slide, none are the only way and all are the correct way--sling shot, shooting hand on the release, support thumb, big toe if that's what works for you. I'd be more interested in knowing to cycle the slide on a no-fire than concern myself with any particular method of releasing the slide.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gunnie and Risasi

·
Registered
Various
Joined
·
15,483 Posts
Either or both. I am left-handed, but right eye dominant. I primarily carry a 1911 right-handed. I have left-handed holsters for my carry handguns in case I want to carry left-handed while I carry a long gun right-handed or carry two full size handguns.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
33,875 Posts
Either or both. I am left-handed, but right eye dominant. I primarily carry a 1911 right-handed. I have left-handed holsters for my carry handguns in case I want to carry left-handed while I carry a long gun right-handed or carry two full size handguns.
Your thumbs must get really confused.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,163 Posts
I train for 1 & 2 hand slide release, both left & right hand. Same goes for a mag change. For consistency, I use the slide release for reloads & rack the slide for FTFs. This has been part of my training routine for 40+ years. My rationale is that in a firefight, I don't want to have to stop & figure out how to reload if one hand is injured or otherwise engaged.

That's my $.02 worth and no, you won't get change back.:smile:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
501 Posts
Discussion Starter #20
I addressed the issue I have actually seen over approximately 12 years and thousands of shooters. I have seen students drop the slide prematurely when using the firing hand thumb...nothing hypothetical about first hand experiences. I said this is how we do it when using 2 hands as a right handed shooter...not that it's the only way.

Using the slide top to drop the slide when executing an emergency reload is undoubtedly a much faster way of getting the gun fueled up and ready to go despite the internet BS that it's a "fine motor skill" (I guess unlike, hitting the mag release, hitting the bolt release/stop on a modern sporting rifle (MSR), action release lever on a shotgun, the tiny bolt release button on a Benelli M2 or M4, clearing a type 3 malfunction or bolt override in a MSR).

As mentioned here lefties have but one option when using the slide stop to drop the slide unless they have an ambidextrous slide stop.

Also, I was only addressing dropping the slide using the slide stop. Not once did I mention this is the only way to get the gun up and running or that it's better than power stroking.

Often times, the most rigid person in the room is one who thinks he or she is NOT being rigid.

Well, it you wish to convert what I said into meaning using one hand only to insert the magazine and drop the slide, go for it. But you clearly understand the controls are designed to be used with the shooting hand only and not "require" a support hand, seeing as you would now be handling two separate items--gun and magazine.

You asked for comments. I think you're creating a solution for a hypothetical problem. There's more than one way to drop a slide, none are the only way and all are the correct way--sling shot, shooting hand on the release, support thumb, big toe if that's what works for you. I'd be more interested in knowing to cycle the slide on a no-fire than concern myself with any particular method of releasing the slide.
 
1 - 20 of 46 Posts
Top