Defensive Carry banner

Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 52 Posts

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,098 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
This debate seems to come up in a lot of threads and I thought I’d make a stand alone thread out of it.

First I understand that some of you live in one of the 9 states that require you to proactively inform the Officer that you are carrying in an official contact. Your state legislature has already made that decision for you, you don’t have an option, we get it.

This question is more for the people who choose to disclose the fact that they are armed to the police when they don’t have to. What is your rationale? Do you think it helps you to do so? Have you ever had it backfire?

As I’ve made clear previously, I choose not to disclose any information I’m not required to, to the police. I have a few different reasons for this they are:

1. I don’t know until I disclose if the cop is pro citizen carry or against it ( dealing W/ CSPD I’m more likely to open my mouth to an anti) I don’t want to hand an anti cop a reason to ruin my night.

2. IMO a traffic stop is a series of problems that the cop has to deal W/ before he can clear the call. If I throw a monkey wrench into the loop by announcing that I’m armed I just handed the cop a whole new batch of problems to solve before he clears the call. That means I’m going to sit on the side of the road longer.

3. There’s no point I have my DL/REG/POI in my hands, on the wheel when the cop gets to my car. He’s not going to suddenly discover I’m armed unless I tell him.

I said this in another thread but I get the impression that the people that go out of their way to inform feel like they’re giving the cop the “secret, good guy, sheepdog hand shake" when they disclose. Also as I’ve mentioned before I’ve had people actually say that handing the cop their CHP lets him know they’re one of “the good guys”.

So what is your rationale? Why do you inform? What good does it do you?

For those who don't Why not?
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
50,603 Posts
In FL one does not have to inform, but I have no problem informing as a 'courtesy' to another firearms owner (LEO's).
In all my dealings with LEO's in this state, all have acted professionally. I guess there could be a situation in which I might not inform, but I'll play that one by ear...:ticking:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,662 Posts
The one time I was stopped while carrying I did out of courtesy, the officer thanked me for doing so and I did not get a ticket.

But, based upon some recent horror stories I have read on this and other forums, I am not sure what I would do in the future.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
24,511 Posts
While it is not required in VA, I go ahead and inform when stopped. When they run your license they will know anyway, so why not tell them right off the bat.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
24,438 Posts
I hand them my Drivers License, Concealed Weapon Permit, Insurance Card, and Registration, thereby informing them out of courtesy that I have a gun on my hip.

On one stop the LEO inquired where the concealed weapon was, and requested that I keep my hands visible. Result: A very expensive traffic ticket.

On one stop the LEO made no comment. Result: A very nice warning to slow down, thereby avoiding a very expensive traffic ticket.

Comment: I have slowed down considerably. I do not like "prizes", and neither does my DW. They impair my "Toy" fund.

I advise them so:

They are told up front I am armed;

They know I passed the background check and am a "good guy" for most practical purposes, present situation notwithstanding;

There are no surprises.

Nobody likes surprises.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,828 Posts
I would inform only if the contact were to occur in a state where my permit is valid and notification is legally required. The commonest scenario involves a traffic stop; the last time I got a traffic citation was 15 or 20 years ago, so I don't expect the decision will arise for me anyway.

I did run into a Border Patrol checkpoint in southern Arizona stopping all traffic. I was in my S2000 with the roof retracted and equipped with a trunk the size of a shoebox. One BP officer asked if I were a US citizen, another led a sniffing dog behind my car. I said "Yes, I am", the officer said "Have a nice day", I drove off without mentioning my Glock 21. Why complicate a smooth contact lasting all of 30 seconds?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,514 Posts
its debated here a lot too, sometimes too hotly and people get on tirades

I highly recommend doing a search on here for "inform" and "notify"
there are plenty of discussions on this
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,098 Posts
Discussion Starter #8
I highly recommend doing a search on here for "inform" and "notify"
there are plenty of discussions on this
I don't want to know what someone's opinion was 2 years ago I want to know what the people that are here now think.

So what about the secret handshake folks? do you think you'll get off lighter if the cop knows you're a good guy?

The "courtesy issue" do you inform store managers when you enter their place of business?
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
24,438 Posts
The "courtesy issue" do you inform store managers when you enter their place of business?
Of course not. Nor the little old lady I help across the street, nor the neighbor to whom I wave. :wave:

The difference is the LEO has initiated contact with me as part of his duty as a LEO, which as we are all sadly aware today, can be very dangerous. It is a courtesy and a tip of the hat to a professional.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,098 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
Maybe a better question is why not inform? Have something to hide?
I made my reasons for not informing very clear in the OP. Do try to keep up.

The difference is the LEO has initiated contact with me as part of his duty as a LEO, which as we are all sadly aware today, can be very dangerous. It is a courtesy and a tip of the hat to a professional.
Ok, so how does my informing the cop I’m armed make his job any safer? Remember, I’m a "certified good guy" so how is my gun a threat to them?

My personal opinion is that those who inform are looking to identify W/ the cop in some way. I’d be willing to bet that most of you fall into the “sheep dog” subset of firearms owners.

I choose not to inform because there is no benefit to me and it could lead to a negative outcome.

Are you really that unsure of your concealment skill?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
835 Posts
its debated here a lot too, sometimes too hotly and people get on tirades

I highly recommend doing a search on here for "inform" and "notify"
there are plenty of discussions on this
Because Texas no longer requires notification, my personal opinion is that most LEO's are likely to consider notification to be a time waster. Otherwise, the legislature would not have abolished the disclosure requirement.

However, we know that 64zebra is a LEO -- and for that reason we ask: Is there a consensus of a preference among you guys?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
289 Posts
While it is not required in VA, I go ahead and inform when stopped. When they run your license they will know anyway, so why not tell them right off the bat.
When they run the plates, they will know the registered owner of the vehicle is authorized to carry.

What if I'm not carrying? I may or may not have my permit with me.

What if someone else is driving my car?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
350 Posts
Unless I'm in a jurisdiction that requires it by law, I won't notify. But I haven't been pulled over in over 15 years, so it's not a day-to-day concern for me.

I don't think notifying about a legally concealed pistol is any more of a courtesy than notifying about a legally held knife or O.C. spray or that I've spent over 20 years practicing various forms of matial arts.

I've heard that some LEOs may actually give you a bit of a break for notifying in a traffic stop situation, but that would never be a consideration for me.

Of course, I would always be polite and respectful to any police officer, as I would to any other human being--even when it is not reciprocated. But being polite and respectful does not mean volunteering information that is not somebody else's business.

And I really, really don't want some police officer to decide to disarm me because I notified and then have an accidental discharge happen. It would also be horrible if I notified, the officer decided to disarm me, and then he discovered I had something on me that is illegal (or he thinks is illegal) that I didn't know about (e.g. finding out that the Seattle Municiple Code has recently changed and my carry knife is now illegal).

Police have policies and procedures for interactions with civilians for good reasons. I don't take offense to the policies and procedures I'm aware of. Likewise, it is good policy for civilians to not provide the police with any more information than is necessary when they are stopped or detained. Good police should never take offense to that.

Edit: one other point--I often have people in my car who I don't want to know that I carry a gun.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,098 Posts
Discussion Starter #15
However, we know that 64zebra is a LEO -- and for that reason we ask: Is there a consensus of a preference among you guys?
If you knew it was the officer's prefference that you allow a search of your vehicle every time they pull you over would you allow it?


Of course, I would always be polite and respectful to any police officer, as I would to any other human being--even when it is not reciprocated. But being polite and respectful does not mean volunteering information that is not somebody else's business.
That is the most well written paragraph in this thread
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
24,438 Posts
Ok, so how does my informing the cop I’m armed make his job any safer? Remember, I’m a "certified good guy" so how is my gun a threat to them?
I merely present the CWP and if they ask if I am armed, I answer honestly. It has nothing to do with making his job "safer". It is merely about full disclosure.

My personal opinion is that those who inform are looking to identify W/ the cop in some way. I’d be willing to bet that most of you fall into the “sheep dog” subset of firearms owners.
I'm glad you're willing to express your personal opinion here so willingly. We'll all get to know and respect you and your opinions more quickly.

I choose not to inform because there is no benefit to me and it could lead to a negative outcome.
Now I understand....you only take actions when they are to your sole benefit. I'm glad we have that out of the way.

I don't really understand your concern about negative outcomes unless there is actually a substantive reason for said outcome..........or an irrational fear of same.......

Are you really that unsure of your concealment skill?
Of course not. That's just silly and argumentative. As you said earlier, "Do try to keep up".
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
714 Posts
I think in Kansas (you other KS guys correct me if I am misinterpreting the law) but a traffic stop would be an official contact and therefore require notification of the officer. That said I have never been asked in the three years I have had my card. One or two stops for lead in foot and one paint exchange; the last being one of the first few days I carried!!

One stop saw KHP and the other were the local PD -- local PD (most at least) are OK with CC --- the Chief is a certified KS CC instructor. I would guess that the KHP's guys fall into the same OK stance as well though we have some areas of the state that I would say you could run into more anti-gun cops (or at least anit civithat others areas
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
350 Posts
Of course not. That's just silly and argumentative. Do try to keep up.
C'mon guys. Let's keep it polite and respectful and resist the temptation of tit for tat. We have so much in common as 2nd Ammedment advocates that it is a shame to go after each other over the little areas where we have reasonable disagreements.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26 Posts
I do not have my CCW yet (class in 6 days), however, after reading all these threads about whether to inform a LEO if I'm carrying or not, I don't think I would inform unless asked by the LEO. My theory is that the LEO is just another citizen doing their job. I was obviously certified and passed the background check, so I can feel comfortable with my ability to be safe. What the LEO does not know, will not hurt them. If they find out I have my permit while looking up my DL#, they can question me all they want and I will be honest.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
908 Posts
Maybe a better question is why not inform? Have something to hide?
And while you're at it, let him search your house... unless you have something to hide.

Obey the law. If the law says you have to inform, inform. If it doesn't say you have to inform, don't.
 
1 - 20 of 52 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top